A further consideration caused me to review the first edition.

P. Schuyler Miller, reviewing the 1948 edition, praised the novel as the opening of "an epic which has no parallel in science fiction."

Reviewing the new edition, Ian Olson notes that the rediscovered essay:

In reviewing the first edition of the book, Bartov wrote:

Fosdick reviewed the first edition of Alcoholics Anonymous in 1939, giving it his approval.

Reviewing the first edition, The Observer wrote:

Chris Hunter reviewed the 1983 edition for Imagine magazine, giving it a positive review.

Several scholars of Hindi and Ramcharitmanas have reviewed the critical edition by Rambhadracharya.

Website Blu-ray.com reviewed the Blu-ray edition of the film, and gave the video quality an almost full mark.

Reviewing the same edition, Groff Conklin termed it "a silly idea inexpertly carried out."