This was a wasted opportunity, a chance to explore an emotionally complex situation between best friends that became just another exploitive TV moment instead.
The 90 minute special was chosen by Tennis Week Magazine as one of the 10 best TV moments from 2007.
Whereas reality shows provided so many great TV moments - "For Love or Money" managed to turn up a few.
James Ash has described the performance as their "best TV moment".
It was the first title he'd won without his murdered father nearby, and another must-see TV moment for an athlete not wearing spikes.
Watch it now and give thanks for this amazing TV moment:
I hope the Emmy judges remember this golden TV moment when they cast their ballots next year.
Importantly, we'd like to hear from you too - about your great TV moments: click onto Memoryshare and tell us your story.
But what are some of the most famous, world-changing TV moments?